Specializing in delicious desserts since 1990

Pies • Cakes • Cheesecakes • Lite Bite Menu
Famous for our Authentic Key West Key Lime Pie

Over 30 years of baking bliss!

Our story began in 1990 when we first opened for business. At that point in time, we were selling only our signature Key Lime Pie dessert.

A true Key West Tradition, our Key Lime Pie is made from a recipe handed down for generations. Famous for over two hundred years in the Florida Keys, this Key Lime treat is now available here for your enjoyment. So sit back, relax, and enjoy an old Key West atmosphere, fantastic desserts, great food and drinks and return to yesteryear.

We also feature a full line of other desserts, beverages, and a Lite Bite menu. For more information and a complete list of our quality products, please contact us today.

You can Dine-In – We Provide Local Delivery and even have a drive-thru on the east side of the building for your convenience.

Our Desserts

Pies

Cakes

Cheesecakes

Cookies

Brownies

View Full Menu

Here’s What People Say About Our Pies & Cakes!

Read More Reviews

      
   The Pie Factory
   351 Google reviews 
  Write a review 
  
 
 
   
 
 
        
   Cara Julian 
 2023-06-30
 
 
  We tried the chocolate and key lime pies. Delicious! Friendly staff and wonderful desserts!
  
 
       
   Elizabeth Stephens 
 2023-05-13
 
 
  Literally the most delightful place. 10/10 recommend. Delicious pie, great service, wonderful all around.
  
 
       
   Jeff Miller 
 2023-05-06
 
 
  We tried several slices of their pies. Had them over a few days of course lol. We had the flourless torte which was amazing. Also the blueberry the key lime, peanut butter chocolate, and just the peanut butter. They were all great in different ways. I went in just wanting a piece of blueberry and key lime. Not one bad one. Our favorites were the torte,key lime, and blueberry.
  
 
       
   Janise Taylor 
 2023-04-25
 
 
  Our Son was visiting  and loves Strawberry pie and a big Thank you to Mary at The Pie Factory she had it made for us today.And it was delicious. We love this place.
  
 
       
   Erin Kirby 
 2023-04-01
 
 
  Stopped in for some key lime pie, was the best authentic key lime pie around! The owner was wonderful! Would definitely stop in again for pie and conversation!