About Us

The Pie Factory Outside Photo

Local Delivery

Local Delivery is available

Call 727-593-1884 to make your order

Drive-thru Lane

Our drive-thru lane is located on the East of the building

Call 727-593-1884 to reserve your desserts today.

Home Delivery with DoorDash

Home Delivery is available with DoorDash.

Mail Order

We ship anywhere in the United States

Call 727-593-1884 to make your order

Wholesale

We sell wholesale to restaurants and fundraisers

Call 727-593-1884 for more information

The Pie Factory Home of Toucan’s Cafe

Specializing in Delicious Desserts since 1990

We are famous for our Key Lime Pie.

It is made from a recipe that has been handed down for generations. 

The Pie Factory is Family Owned and Operated since 1990

Our story began in 1990 when we first opened for business. At that point and time, we were selling only our signature Key Lime Pie dessert.

A true Key West Tradition Our Key Lime Pie is made from a recipe handed down for generations. Famous for over two hundred years in the Florida Keys, this Key Lime treat is now available here for your enjoyment. So sit back, relax, and enjoy an old Key West atmosphere, fantastic desserts, great food and drinks and return to yesteryear.

Over the years, we have added tons of delicious items to our menu and now offer over 35 different kinds of pies as well as cakes and a variety of pastries and cookies. We sell retail directly to the public and wholesale to restaurants and fundraisers for community events. Come on in and visit us today and let us satisfy your sweet tooth. You will be glad that you did!

You can Dine-In – We Provide Local Delivery and even have a drive-thru on the east side of the building for your convenience. We also ship pies via mail order across the United States.

Call us today at 727-593-1884 to reserve a Pie or Cake. We will have it ready for you when you arrive.

Chocolate Thunder Cake

People Sincerely
Enjoy Our Pies & Cakes!

What a fun place to visit! An entire place full of delicious pies. They also serve a limited food menu including soup. But, back to the pies! They are all made fresh and they look delicious and with so many choices it was tough to decide. Good news they sell by the slice so we got a variety. The customer service was excellent, the gentleman was quite but, friendly and the cashier woman was also very sweet. She was kind enough to mark each container for us. We got ours to go but, there is plenty of seating.
Kristy O/M
The pie here is really fantastic! I had the blackberry pie and it was delish! You can buy by the slice or whole pie. All the crusts are homemade. I'll definitely make the trip back to Indian Shores to get this little slice of heaven.
Elisa Y
So many pies!!! I bought several pies for a party. They were all delicious. I love that they have a drive thru, too.
Rebecca D

Most Popular
Pies We Have!

Key Lime Supreme

Authentic Key West key Lime Pie (10″)

Apple Berry Sampler

Apple Berry Sampler Pie (10″)

1/4 each of Apple, Cherry, Peach, and Blueberry

Awesome Apple Pie

Awesome Apple Pie (10″)

Apple Caramel Nut

Apple Caramel Nut Pie (10″)

See Full Menu
Key Lime Pie