Menu
Our Most Popular Pies
• Authentic Key West Key Lime
• Apple Berry Sampler
• Awesome Apple
• Apple Caramel Nut
• Toucan Sampler
• Peanuttier Peanut Butter
– Pies –
Authentic Key West Key Lime
Apple
Dutch Apple
Cherry
Peach
Blueberry
Strawberry*
Strawberry Rhubarb
Fruit of the Forest
Apple Caramel Nut
Pecan
Pumpkin
Sweet Potato
French Silk
Chocolate Cream
Kentucky Bourbon
Boston Cream*
Lemon Meringue
Chocolate Meringue
Coconut Cream Meringue
Coconut Cream de la Cream
Chocolate Oreo Bash
Peanut Butter Fudge Swirl
Peanuttier Peanut Butter*
– No Sugar Added Pies –
(For our diabetic friends — or anyone watching their sugar intake)
Apple*
Cherry*
Peach*
Blueberry*
Chocolate Cream
– Sampler Pies –
Toucan’s Sampler
Key Lime, Peanut Butter Fudge Swirl, Oreo Bash
Apple Berry Sampler
Apple, Cherry, Peach, Blueberry
All American Apple Pie**
Apple, Apple Razberry, Apple Caramel Nut, Cinnamon Apple
* Denotes a Special Order Item | ** Denotes a Seasonal Item
– Cakes –
Key Lime
Carrot
Coconut
Cannoli*
Tira Misu
Pina Colada*
Red Velvet*
Boston Cream
Oreos N Cream
Lemon
Chocolate Thunder
Peanuttier Chocolate
German Chocolate
Mint Chocolate
Chocolate Razberry
Raspberry Almond
Strawberry Shortcake*
Black Forrest
Limoncello
– Specialty Cakes –
Wedding
Birthday
Anniversary
Retirement and Other
All Occasions
* Denotes a Special Order Item | ** Denotes a Seasonal Item
– Cookies –
Decadent Triple Chocolate Cookie / 4.5 oz*
Chocolate Chip / 1.5 oz
Chocolate Chunk / 4.5 oz
Peanut Butter / 1.5 oz
Oatmeal Raisin / 1.5 oz
White Chocolate Macadamia / 1.5 oz
White Chocolate Raspberry / 1.5 oz
Banana Cream / 1.5 oz
* Denotes a Special Order Item | ** Denotes a Seasonal Item
– Cheesecakes –
Authentic New York Style
Salted Caramel
Strawberry Swirl
Triple Chocolate
Turtle
White Chocolate Raspberry
– Pastries –
Brownies
Mini Cannolis*
Eclairs*
Shooters*
Petit Fours*
Key Lime Muffin
Mini Desserts*
Specialty Breads
* Denotes a Special Order Item | ** Denotes a Seasonal Item
Specialty Breads
Banana Nut
Blueberry
Pistachio
Pumpkin**
Orange Cranberry Nut**
Lite Bite Menu
Quiche
Shepherd Pie
Hot Dog
Chili
Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup
Southern BBQ
Drinks
Milk Shakes
Smoothies
Coffee
Tea
Lemonade
Soda
Milk
Floats
Dine In - Take Out - Drive-Thru - Delivery
Gift Certificates Available • Wholesale to restaurants/fundraisers