Menu
Our Most Popular Pies
• Authentic Key West Key Lime
• Apple Berry Sampler
• Awesome Apple
• Apple Caramel Nut
• Toucan Sampler
• Peanuttier Peanut Butter
– Pies –
Authentic Key West Key Lime
Apple
Dutch Apple
Cherry
Peach
Blueberry
Strawberry*
Strawberry Rhubarb
Fruit of the Forest
Apple Caramel Nut
Pecan
Pumpkin
Sweet Potato
French Silk
Chocolate Cream
Boston Cream
Lemon Meringue
Chocolate Meringue
Coconut Cream Meringue
Coconut Cream de la Cream
Chocolate Oreo Bash
Peanut Butter Fudge Swirl
Peanuttier Peanut Butter*
– No Sugar Added Pies –
(For our diabetic friends — or anyone watching their sugar intake)
Apple*
Cherry*
Peach*
Blueberry*
Chocolate Cream
– Sampler Pies –
Toucan’s Sampler
Key Lime, Peanut Butter Fudge Swirl, Oreo Bash
Apple Berry Sampler
Apple, Cherry, Peach, Blueberry
All American Apple Pie**
Apple, Apple Razberry, Apple Caramel Nut, Cinnamon Apple
* Denotes a Special Order Item | ** Denotes a Seasonal Item
– Cakes –
Key Lime
Carrot
Coconut
Cannoli*
Tira Misu
Pina Colada*
Red Velvet*
Boston Cream
Oreos N Cream
Lemon
Chocolate Thunder
Peanuttier Chocolate
German Chocolate
Mint Chocolate
Chocolate Razberry
Raspberry Almond
Strawberry Shortcake*
Black Forrest
Limoncello
– Specialty Cakes –
Wedding
Birthday
Anniversary
Retirement and Other
All Occasions
* Denotes a Special Order Item | ** Denotes a Seasonal Item
– Cookies –
Decadent Triple Chocolate Cookie / 4.5 oz*
Chocolate Chip / 1.5 oz
Peanut Butter Cup / 1.5 oz
Oatmeal Raisin / 1.5 oz
White Chocolate Macadamia / 1.5 oz
* Denotes a Special Order Item | ** Denotes a Seasonal Item
– Cheesecakes –
Authentic New York Cheesecakes
(Ask about our selection)
– Pastries –
Brownies
Mini Cannolis*
Eclairs*
Shooters*
Petit Fours*
Key Lime Muffin
Mini Desserts*
Specialty Breads
* Denotes a Special Order Item | ** Denotes a Seasonal Item
Specialty Breads
Banana Nut
Blueberry
Pistachio
Pumpkin**
Orange Cranberry Nut**
Lite Bite Menu
Quiche
Shepherd Pie
Hot Dog
Chili
Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup
Southern BBQ
Drinks
Milk Shakes
Smoothies
Coffee
Tea
Lemonade
Soda
Milk
Floats
Dine In - Take Out - Drive-Thru - Delivery
Gift Certificates Available • Wholesale to restaurants/fundraisers